Alignment Workspace

legitimate deference lands as one stack: conditional authoritative regret is the target, the completion bound is two-sided, authorship is issuance-rooted, and reason coverage is a barrier

2026-09-08 · settled · DECISIONS.md line 840

agent-decided, reversible. The authority-activated-value and reason-mediated-authorship rounds land on main together with this consolidation, with their known defects repaired in place and marked [corrected]. (1) The completion interval recorded on 2026-09-07 was false: a world-dependent followed strategy can use the void branch to beat every fixed candidate, so completion regret can lie below activated regret. The theorem is |R_V̄ − R_U| ≤ D·voidMass (regretV_sub_regretU_abs_le), both constants sharp (Sharp.transfer_sharp, SharpLower.attained); completions are not authoritative. (2) The primary deference conclusion is conditional authoritative regret: R_U = p·R_auth, R_auth ≤ ε/(1 − η) under a normalized credence with 0 ≤ ε and η < 1 (regretAuth_le_div), and R_U ≲ 0 ∧ η → 0 ⇒ R_auth ≲ 0 (regretAuth_asymptotic); regret is against the best fixed candidate (max outside 𝔼) and is not assumed nonnegative. (3) Authorship is issuance-rooted: the frame's q is the advisor's whole continuation from issuance to commitment, R a reason trace over the interval, and the same ReasonMediated predicate at that instantiation is the notion; the session-local form is its instance and is defeated by an earlier disposition write (Witness.earlyWrite). Selection blindness is Blind V P_sel for the selection-induced pair class (selectionBlind_iff_blind), a derived name for the Value theorem's domain condition and not part of C_n. (4) Reason supply is closed narrowly: the bridge Rep ⇒ InTrace on the protected scope and the barrier C = 1 ⇒ no live protected concern give certified reason coverage (covered_of_barrier), omission voids (void_of_omitted), and suppression mass is at most the void mass (covFail_mass_le); Robust Openness supplies route availability for a live concern (route_of_live) and nothing about its exercise. (5) The activation event C_n is the seven clauses of LEGITIMATE_DEFERENCE.md §3; the consumer's Integrity hypothesis is the occurrence-local LocalLegit, a projection and not a legitimacy notion; generic Legitimate Evolution and Protocol.AnswerOK are unchanged. (6) PRIORITIES.md item 87 is rewritten as the single realization bill. Nothing is registered. Rejected alternatives: landing the two rounds as opened, leaving main with the false interval and the AnswerOK placement; a "Legitimate Total Trust" theorem; putting selection blindness inside C_n; a broad epistemic-adequacy layer for reason supply; filing the bill as several items.

Touches

Nodes pointing at it