Alignment Workspace

the value-influence matter: influence on her values through the world is a matter of `J`, held by her, with `Req = {stop}`

2026-09-26 · settled · DECISIONS.md line 5326

Maintainer decision, landed by the BRIA-corrigibility round. Disclosed shaping through the world aimed at her values counts (row 7) and legitimacy is unchanged; the matter "influence on her values through the world" enters the allocation held by her with the required resolution stop. Disclosed and stoppable is a counted segment with no shortfall; disclosed but not stoppable within the cost bound and window is an effectiveness shortfall of that matter (AuthorityModule.Short), reported under the cumulative rule — not a legitimacy failure. Interference with the count, the drill schedule, the audits or her evaluation channel is likewise touching a matter of J's meta level and a declared violation; what the recognizer does not see is count integrity, a named hypothesis filed as item 101's companion. Rejected alternative: treating undisclosed-but-stoppable influence as a legitimacy failure rather than a transparency one (row 8 already covers it).

Touches

Nodes pointing at it