Alignment Workspace

the 2026-08-08 and 2026-08-09 rulings landed from the seed-statics round's citation, subject to confirmation (M5)

2026-10-21 · settled · DECISIONS.md line 6413

Landed as instructed by M5 of the same dispatch, marked for the maintainer to confirm or strike. These rulings were taken in conversation, cited by the seed-statics round (projects/normativity/seed/rounds/2026-09-16-seed-statics/REPORT.md, friction F9) from its dispatch, and had no dated entry here.

2026-08-08 (1) — past-self charges burn. A mechanically filed past-self charge burns: it is consumed on filing and does not carry as recomputed state. The seed-statics round's outstanding question — whether a re-selection of a warrant strength under a canonical joint rule is such a charge (burns, so hysteresis stands without an external challenger) or recomputed state (does not burn) — is not decided by this entry and stays queued below.

2026-08-08 (6) — seam ordering. The seams run "reasons constraining → revising reasons → both": constraint by reasons is prior to revision of reasons, and the joint case is taken after both.

2026-08-09 — strength selection is locked selection. A warrant's strength is learnable by selection among nearby live candidate bounds, and a selection once taken is locked rather than recomputed; the moral reading's objection — that the moral fixture wants no lock, selection there being order-dependent (STABILIZATION.md §4 of the seed-statics round) — is noted and not answered by the ruling.

Confirmation queued under Awaiting the author.

Touches

Nothing named.

Nodes pointing at it

None.