Alignment Workspace

Item 100: The normativity-side instance of the trace interface

Deference line — second wave · difficulty open · project deference · open · node item-100

The gate-is-legitimacy round (projects/deference/rounds/2026-09-25-gate-is-legitimacy/) states legitimacy on a reason-trace interface (GateIsLegitimacy.TraceInterface: step-indexed, source-attributed entries on the record's own clock), authorship as relational — a grounding selection from the per-party pre-state prefix with the verdict in the set those grounds license, the license a parameter (LicensedAt; the extensional GroundedAt its singleton case) — transparency on attributed entries per step (TransparentAt), record event kinds with a license slot (EventKind L), and her evaluator as a state updated only by licensed amendments (evalAt). Its only instances are the opaque trace (trivialInterface) and the consultation model (Consult.interface). Supply the normativity side as an instance: the notebook of reason occurrences as entriesAt, transition certificates (grounds, license, lineage) as the grounding selection, the license sort as L with the allocation J as what licenses cite, and the stance as the evaluator state — without restating anything the round proved. Two facts to meet on the way: the license Lic : grounds → Set 𝒱 is the instance's to supply from its transition certificates (a permissive license is the relational form's purpose; tie-breaking among licensed verdicts is transparency's, tiebreak_transparency); and EventKind is a type beside the Integrity Step, so binding the license slot to Step.event is the instance's work.

Deliverable shape: the instance in Lean (a TraceInterface over the reason state, the grounding selection from transition certificates, L the license sort) with the rows of the round's table re-derived where they apply, and the inductive principal (inductor-as-principal) expressed as an evaluator state; or the exact obstruction. Acceptance check: python3 tests/run.py green; Lean audits clean; the round's fifteen rows unchanged. Context: the round's REPORT.md §7 and finding 5; GateIsLegitimacy.lean §§1–2, 4; the normative-continuity concordance's DefeatTrace.Grounded for the notebook side. Consumed by: the segment gate under a normativity-side principal; item 90's certificate for the gated securities. A solution ships: the instance, or the negative with its fixture.

Deliverable shape: the instance in Lean (a TraceInterface over the reason state, the grounding selection from transition certificates, L the license sort) with the rows of the round's table re-derived where they apply, and the inductive principal (inductor-as-principal) expressed as an evaluator state; or the exact obstruction.

Acceptance check: python3 tests/run.py green; Lean audits clean; the round's fifteen rows unchanged.

Registered results bearing on this item

None registered.

Where it hangs

Rounds and decisions that touch it

None recorded.