Alignment Workspace

legitimacy.endpoint-only-insufficient

and · drafted

Statement

Exact counterexample: a two-transition evolution open at both endpoints whose middle state has a live concern with no adequate route; it is not a legitimate segment. This is why openness is required at every state.

Source

projects/normativity/CLAIMS.md, entry legitimacy.endpoint-only-insufficient (class lean-proved, status superseded, origin round 2026-09-07-final-pressure-pass; answers item 78). Documentation: verification: projects/normativity/legitimacy/rounds/2026-09-07-final-pressure-pass/THEOREMS.md; context: projects/normativity/legitimacy/rounds/2026-09-07-final-pressure-pass/READINESS.md. The signature of Workspace.Normativity.Contrib.LegitimateEvolution.Witness.endpoint_only_insufficient in lean/Workspace/Normativity/Contrib/OpenIntegrityEvolution.lean (an alias declared in lean/Workspace/Normativity/Contrib/LegitimateEvolution.lean).

Notes

Filed by the map-as-canonical round (prompts/2026-10-22-map-as-canonical) from the registry entry and the declaration's signature; its hypotheses are unread (ruling F1, 2026-10-23): the record's Source carries the signature verbatim, and a reader files the hypothesis leaves. Registry note: Exact counterexample: a two-transition evolution open at both endpoints whose middle state has a live concern with no adequate route; it is not a legitimate segment. This is why openness is required at every state. Superseded 2026-09-25 by openness.endpoint-only-insufficient; the declaration name is kept resolving by a deprecated alias for one release. The registry's answers_item is the priorities pointer to item 78 (ruling F2).

Bridge card

Connected to no informal claim yet: held by integrity-and-record.

Declaration Workspace.Normativity.Contrib.LegitimateEvolution.Witness.endpoint_only_insufficient in lean/Workspace/Normativity/Contrib/LegitimateEvolution.lean (record legitimacy.endpoint-only-insufficient.record)

Registry legitimacy.endpoint-only-insufficient: class lean-proved, status superseded, review ci-only, origin round 2026-09-07-final-pressure-pass; bears on item 78

Bridge (formalizer-stated; legitimacy.endpoint-only-insufficient.bridge, drafted):

The statement of record of `legitimacy.endpoint-only-insufficient` formalizes the registered claim as the registry reads it: endpoint-only openness admits laundered exclusion.

Hypotheses: unread (the record's Source carries the signature; a reader files them).

Completeness (legitimacy.endpoint-only-insufficient.complete): No premise beyond the signature's binders enters the declaration; the kernel checks it as stated. The result is the record, this leaf and the bridge, and its hypotheses are unread: the record's Source carries the signature verbatim and no hypothesis leaf is filed until a reader files one.

Author and human events

Author @smithy-verity; version 1; size M.

No human event has touched this node.

Edges

Above

Children

Work pointers

Ranking (the lens, not the structure)
{
 "status": "open",
 "diagnosis": null,
 "flags": [
  "held by integrity-and-record",
  "hypotheses unread",
  "superseded by openness.endpoint-only-insufficient"
 ],
 "V": {
  "V_prior": null,
  "display": "2",
  "headline": 2,
  "ref": 2,
  "valid": 2,
  "weaker": "both"
 },
 "belief": null,
 "draft": "ai"
}

Say something about it

Each verb opens a prefilled issue; a round files what lands as the ledger event it is.

comment · challenge · estimate · want