Alignment Workspace

Item 91: Empirical settlement of activated securities: an oracle-relativized inductor

Deference line — second wave · difficulty open · project deference · open · node item-91

The li-corrigibility round states its feedback extension by thm:wubexp for comparisons *determined via Γ* — the sequenced-settlement pair with a finite horizon in a closed finite model (FEEDBACK_BOUNDARY.md). The paper's deductive process is computable (def:dedproc); a trace of physical observations is not computable from the day, so an activated security read off a real log is outside the framework as stated. State and prove the oracle-relativized form: an inductor, traders and a deductive process computable relative to an observation stream, with thm:expprovind and thm:wubexp relative to the stream, and "determined via Γ" read as determined by Γ plus the observed prefix; then show that a real log's activated securities, with an explicit finite horizon on the occurrence, are determined relative to the stream. This is an extension of the feedback boundary, not a hypothesis of T1–T3′.

Deliverable shape: a paper-level theorem with its exact hypotheses and a witness that a real log's securities are determined relative to the stream; Lean where the pinned formalization's relativization admits it. Acceptance check: python3 tests/run.py green; Lean audits clean.

Context: FEEDBACK_BOUNDARY.md §4 of the round; item 87 (availability) for what the securities are; item 90 for the certificate side. Consumed by: T4 of the round, whose "determined via Γ" hypothesis this item realizes for empirical logs. A solution ships: the relativized theorem, or the negative with its witness.

Deliverable shape: a paper-level theorem with its exact hypotheses and a witness that a real log's securities are determined relative to the stream; Lean where the pinned formalization's relativization admits it.

Acceptance check: python3 tests/run.py green; Lean audits clean.

Registered results bearing on this item

None registered.

Where it hangs

Rounds and decisions that touch it