Alignment Workspace

Item 90: The generability certificate of the soft-weighted finite-menu constraint

Deference line — second wave · difficulty open · project deference · open · node item-90

— *narrowed 2026-09-15: T3's own certificate is constructed (LICorrigibilityCertificate.lean); what remains is T3′'s*

The li-corrigibility round (projects/deference/rounds/2026-09-15-li-corrigibility/) learns the corrigibility inequality by thm:expprovind, and its landing pass constructs the pinned-interface generability certificate for the compiled pair constraint (MediatedPair.syntaxOf, li_bypass_le_compiled, inhabited by Witness.li_instance). The finite-menu form T3′ — max_{q ∈ Q_n} [E_n(U_q) − E_n(U_𝔠q) − λ E_n(G_δ,q) − E_n(G_ρ,q) − E_n(G_M,q)] ≲_n 0 over a polynomial-size efficiently generated menu — is proved through the near-argmax weighting whose kernel is Lean (softWeight_aggregate_ge, uniform_of_soft) but whose P-generability is paper-level: the weights are expressible features folded over the growing menu (max chains, a sum, one safe reciprocal, and the mesh-expectation scores of every pair), and the pinned splice suite mirrors the feature constructors one at a time (RpnSpliceStream.serialize_*) with a variable-width fold only for token concatenation (concatVar). Build the feature-chain fold and the LUVCombinationSyntax of (B'_n), so that T3′ is mechanized end to end as T3 is.

Deliverable shape: Lean declarations discharging LUVCombinationSyntax for the soft-weighted combination of a polynomial-size generated menu of compiled pairs, audited to the three axioms, with the T3′ endpoint stated in the form of li_bypass_le_compiled. Acceptance check: python3 tests/run.py green; Lean audits clean.

Context: LUV_COMPILATION.md §2 and §4, LI_CORRIGIBILITY.md §3 of the round; the pinned formalization's Construction/Witnesses/LUVSyntax.lean for the certificate shape and its own triangularSoftmaxPoly for a fold of the same kind. Consumed by: T3′ of the round; any registration of the finite-menu theorem. A solution ships: the certificate, or the exact combinator the pinned suite lacks.

2026-09-25 (gate-is-legitimacy round): the segment gate's asymptotic half is the classification table read through Expectation Provability Induction (GateIsLegitimacy.li_manip_le, an instance of li_gated_le): a row theorem "pattern ⇒ ¬Counted" is the per-world hypothesis, and what the theory must contain is the consultation model's semantics, the decidable checker's verdict and the declared reference. What this item's shape now also covers: the P-generability of the gated securities — that the checker's verdict and the model's run are expressible features — beside T3′'s weighting. The finite-time half needs none of this (li_gate_finite).

Deliverable shape: Lean declarations discharging LUVCombinationSyntax for the soft-weighted combination of a polynomial-size generated menu of compiled pairs, audited to the three axioms, with the T3′ endpoint stated in the form of li_bypass_le_compiled.

Acceptance check: python3 tests/run.py green; Lean audits clean.

Registered results bearing on this item

None registered.

Where it hangs

Rounds and decisions that touch it